Justifying and Trust

Why do we justify ourselves to others? Do we need that external acceptance and validation? Are we worried that others do not trust or believe us? Are there any negative repercussions to over justifying? How do trust issues connect to justifying?
“Those who lack courage will always find a philosophy to justify.”
Albert Camus
1. Justifying
When we are justifying, we are on the defensive or making an excuse. We are demonstrating a need to prove or show someone that what we are saying, doing, or feeling is accurate and true. Maybe they don’t trust us. To feel mistrusted is not a comfortable place to be. Our justifying appears, on the surface, to be a way out of this discomfort. However, by justifying we are actually feeding the doubt, not only in the other person but also in ourselves.
In Shakespeare’s Hamlet: “The lady doth protest too much, methinks,” summarizes how justifying can sometimes backfire and give the mistrustful person more cause to doubt you. In ourselves, the more we justify to others, the more we sow the seeds of self-doubt. We can become so accustomed to defending our views or our actions that we automatically justify when we feel any hint of mistrust. One modern day example would be: I say, “I learned that __________ causes _________.” They say, “Oh, that’s interesting. I’ll Google that.” Google becomes the mechanism of cross validation because I don’t know if I believe or trust what you are telling me.
“I trust no one, not even myself.”
– Joseph Stalin
2. Trust
Trust is the firm belief in the reliability or ability of someone or something. According to the Harvard Business Review (2020), trust has three core attributes. Trust requires authenticity, which means I am experiencing the real you. Trust requires logic, which means I know you can do it; your reasoning and judgement are sound. And, trust requires empathy, which means I believe you care about me and my success. As you can readily see, this is a high bar for many to reach. Trust can be fractured very quickly. One bad experience, piled onto many other bad experiences, can make trust almost unattainable for some people. In the Google example, all three trust attributes are being questioned by the receiver. When we experience a constant barrage of questioning our thoughts or actions, we become more vulnerable to chasing mistrust away by justifying ourselves. This becomes a form of entrapment. It is not only entrapment to others but also to ourselves.
“The best proof of love is trust.”
- Dr. Joyce Brothers
3. Self-Doubt
The real costs of justifying are observed over time. When we reach the automaticity of justifying on demand, we are building a mountain of self-doubt. Over time justifying begats more justifying. Our sensitivity to believe in ourselves is undermined by a constant need for approval from others. When my thoughts and actions are perpetually questioned and not accepted by others, how do I accept myself?
The repeated reinforcement schedule of justifying also enables others to keep having doubts about us. There is an unrelenting need for validation, which is beyond our grasp. The paradox of justifying is that it leads to more self-doubt and lower self-esteem. At some point, justifying to others has the potential to destroy our trust in ourselves.
“I spoke without fear of contradiction. I simply did not suffer self-doubt.”
- Elia Kazan
We can regain trust in ourselves by finding our validation from within. The dependency on other people’s validation is not a stable source. Our sense of self must be nurtured from within. Self-doubt is manufactured internally by our need to be accepted by others. Justifying will not achieve this goal. To initiate one’s goal of self-acceptance and self-trust, we need to remind ourselves to just stop justifying.
Authored by Psychologist Dr. Bruce Wilson
© Copyright 2022 Dr. Bruce Wilson. All rights reserved. Permission to publish granted by Dr. Bruce Wilson
